Skip to content

Journal

How to check what your SEO provider changed on your website

If you pay for SEO but cannot see what was done, these checks show what changed on your site, using free tools and a few direct questions.

The short answer

To check what SEO work was done, compare your live pages against a dated change log. Use view-source or Search Console's URL Inspection to confirm titles, descriptions, canonicals and structured data, check the Pages and Sitemaps reports, compare old versions in your CMS or the Wayback Machine, and test redirects and internal links yourself.

Key points

  • Ask for a change log listing each URL, the old value, the new value and the date.
  • View the page source or use URL Inspection to confirm titles, descriptions, canonicals and markup.
  • Search Console's Pages and Sitemaps reports show whether Google can find and index your pages.
  • CMS revision history and the Wayback Machine let you compare a page before and after.
  • A good report ties every claimed change to a URL you can check yourself.

Why is it so hard to tell what SEO work was done?

Most SEO changes are invisible to a visitor. A new title tag shows in the browser tab and in search results, not on the page itself. A canonical tag, a redirect rule, structured data or a robots directive sits in the code or the server settings. So an owner can pay for months of work, look at the homepage, see nothing different, and have no easy way to tell whether the work is subtle or simply did not happen.

Reports often make this worse. A monthly PDF of ranking charts, traffic graphs and a list of "tasks completed" describes activity without tying it to anything you can check. "Optimised on-page elements" could mean ten careful title rewrites or nothing at all.

The answer is not to become an SEO specialist. It is to insist that every claimed change points to a specific URL and a specific value, then to spot-check a few of them with free tools. The checks below need no coding and take a few minutes per page once you have done them once.

What should you ask your SEO provider for first?

Start with a change log: a plain list of what was changed, where and when. It is the most useful document in any SEO engagement, because it turns vague claims into things you can verify. A provider doing real work on your site should be able to produce one easily, since they need the same record to manage their own work.

If the answer is that changes are "ongoing" or "behind the scenes" with no list, treat that as a finding in itself. Some work, such as keyword research or outreach to other websites, does not change your site directly, but it should still be described specifically: which pages the research shaped, which websites were approached and what came of it.

  • The exact URL of each page that was changed.
  • What was changed: title, meta description, canonical, redirect, structured data, internal link, content or a robots rule.
  • The value before the change and the value after it.
  • The date the change went live, and who made it.
  • Whether the change was checked on the live site afterwards, and when.

How do you check titles, descriptions, canonicals and structured data?

The quickest check is the page source. Open the page in a desktop browser, right-click and choose "View page source", or type view-source: in front of the address in Chrome. Then use find (Ctrl+F, or Cmd+F on a Mac) to search for the tags below and compare what you see with the change log.

View-source shows what the server sends, which is not always what Google ends up processing if your site builds parts of the page with JavaScript. For Google's version, use the URL Inspection tool in Google Search Console. Google's help pages explain that it reports on Google's indexed version of a page and can run a live test of the current URL. Paste the address in, run the live test, open the tested page and search its HTML the same way.

If the change log says structured data was added, Google's Rich Results Test will show whether Google can read the markup on the live page for the rich result types it supports, and the Schema Markup Validator at schema.org checks the rest. Valid markup helps search engines understand the page, but it does not promise any special display in results, so treat any report that claims otherwise with caution.

  • Search for <title> to see the page title Google may use in results.
  • Search for name="description" to see the meta description.
  • Search for rel="canonical" to see which URL the page names as its main version.
  • Search for application/ld+json to see structured data, such as LocalBusiness or Article markup.
  • Search for noindex to see whether the page is asking search engines to leave it out.

What do Search Console's Pages and Sitemaps reports tell you?

If you do not already have access to your website's Search Console property, ask for it first. The property belongs to your business. A provider should be added as a user, not hold the only login. Once you are in, two reports give a quick, honest picture of whether the work is helping Google find your pages.

The Page indexing report, shown as Pages in the menu, tells you how many of your URLs Google has indexed and lists reasons others are not, such as "Excluded by 'noindex' tag", "Duplicate without user-selected canonical" or "Page with redirect". Google's documentation is clear that not every URL on a site should be indexed, so the aim is not to clear every row. Look for your important pages in the indexed list, and for movement in the right direction after work your provider says fixes indexing.

The Sitemaps report shows which sitemap files have been submitted, when Google last read them and how many URLs it discovered. If your provider says they fixed or submitted a sitemap, the date and status here should reflect it. If new pages were published, open the sitemap file in your browser, often at /sitemap.xml or /sitemap_index.xml, and confirm they are listed.

How do you compare a page before and after a change?

A change log tells you what was meant to change. To confirm it, you need an earlier version of the page to compare against. There are two practical places to find one.

Your content management system may keep a revision history. WordPress, for example, stores revisions of posts and pages showing who edited what and when, and many other platforms have something similar. If your provider says they rewrote a service page last month, the history should show an edit around that date. SEO plugin fields such as the title and meta description are not always included in revisions, so check the live source as well.

The Wayback Machine from the Internet Archive keeps snapshots of many public web pages over time. Enter your page's address at web.archive.org, pick a date before the work started, view that snapshot's source and compare its title, description and canonical with today's. Coverage is uneven, especially for small sites and deeper pages, so a missing snapshot proves nothing either way. The archive's help pages also explain how to save a page yourself, which is worth doing for key pages before a new engagement begins.

Redirects are easy to test. Type an old URL that your provider says now redirects into the browser and watch the address bar: it should arrive at the intended new page in one step. If it lands on the homepage, an error page or a different page from the one in the change log, the redirect is wrong or missing. A free online header checker will show the status code too. Google's guidance on redirects treats permanent server-side redirects, 301 and 308, as a strong signal that the new URL should be the one shown in results.

Watch for chains, where one URL redirects to another that redirects again. Each extra step slows visitors down and adds work for crawlers, and chains tend to build up after several rounds of site changes. A careful provider flattens them so every old URL goes straight to its final destination.

Internal links are checked on the page itself. If the log says links were added from your blog posts to a service page, open those posts and find them. Hover over each link to confirm it points to the right address rather than a redirected or broken one, and that the clickable words describe the destination in plain language rather than saying "click here".

What questions should you ask your SEO provider?

Direct questions get clearer answers than a request for "an update". These are fair to ask any provider, and a confident one will welcome them.

What matters is how specific the answers are. "We improved technical health" is not an answer. "We fixed the redirect chains on the old blog URLs, listed here with dates" is one you can check in five minutes.

Ask where the work is blocked, too. Many engagements stall because recommendations sit with a developer who never gets time to implement them. If your provider only sends recommendations, find out how many have actually been applied, and by whom.

  • Which URLs did you change this month, and can I see the before and after values?
  • Who makes the changes on the site, and do you need our approval first?
  • How do you check that a change is live, and that it is still live a few weeks later?
  • Which issues you reported earlier are still open, and why?
  • What did you do that did not change the website, and what did it produce?
  • Which recommendations are waiting on us or our developer?

What does a good SEO provider report look like?

A good report is short, specific and checkable. It leads with what changed on the site, then what changed in search, then what is planned next and why. Charts are fine, but they support the change log; they do not replace it.

It should also be honest about what it does not know. If a figure could not be measured, the report should say so rather than estimate it. And it should not claim that a ranking or traffic change was caused by one particular edit unless there is clear evidence, because search results move for many reasons at once.

At Deylaxy we make the changes on the client's website ourselves, wait for approval first (unless the client has chosen to let small changes go ahead without a reply), and check every change on the live site once it is made. That is a fair standard to ask of any provider. Whoever does your SEO, you should be able to pick any line in the report, open the page and see the change for yourself.

  • A change list with the URL, before value, after value and date for every edit.
  • A note of how and when each change was verified on the live page.
  • Search Console figures from your own property, with the date range stated.
  • Open issues ranked by impact, with who is responsible for each.
  • Plain explanations of any jargon, and no promises about rankings.

Frequently asked questions

How often should an SEO provider share a change log?

Monthly is a sensible minimum, but the change log should be updated as work happens rather than written up at the end of the month. Each entry should include the URL, what changed, the before and after values and the date. A shared document you can open at any time is better than a monthly attachment, because it lets you check a change in the week it was made.

Can an SEO provider make changes without telling me?

They can if they have access to your website, which is why the terms should be agreed in writing. Decide which changes need your approval before they go live and which small fixes can go ahead with notice. Either way, every change should appear in the change log. Keep your own administrator login and Search Console ownership so you can review the site and remove access if needed.

Why can't I see any difference on my site after SEO work?

Many SEO changes do not alter what visitors see. Title tags, meta descriptions, canonical tags, structured data and redirects live in the code or server settings, so you need to view the page source or use URL Inspection in Search Console to see them. Content and internal link changes are visible, so if those are reported and you cannot find them, ask which URL and which paragraph changed.

How long after an SEO change should results appear?

There is no fixed timeline. Google has to recrawl the page, process the change and reassess it alongside everything else, which can take days for frequently crawled pages and much longer for others. You can confirm a change is live straight away, and URL Inspection shows when Google last crawled the page. Any provider promising a specific ranking by a specific date is claiming something nobody controls.

What if my SEO provider will not share what they changed?

Treat it as a serious warning sign. Work done on your website should be visible to you, and a provider has no good reason to keep it from the site owner. Ask in writing for a list of changed URLs with dates. If none arrives, review the CMS revision history and user activity, compare key pages in the Wayback Machine, and decide whether the engagement is delivering what you pay for.

Sources

  1. 1.URL Inspection tool (Search Console Help)
  2. 2.Page indexing report (Search Console Help)
  3. 3.Manage your sitemaps using the Sitemaps report (Search Console Help)
  4. 4.Redirects and Google Search (Google Search Central)
  5. 5.Using the Wayback Machine (Internet Archive Help Center)

Get an independent, evidence-based reading of your site to compare against what your current SEO reports say.

Get your free Visibility Intelligence Audit

A concise reading of verified signals across search engines and AI answers, enough to recognise the gaps, not a playbook for competitors.